As a Junior – 2018:
- Selected in the 16th round of the 2018 MLB draft by the Pittsburg Pirates
- Named to ABCA/Rawlings NCAA DIII All-America First Team
- Selected to D3baseball.com All-America Second Team
- VaSID Pitcher of the Year
- VaSID All-State First Team
- All-South Region First Team
- ODAC Pitcher of the Year
- Named ODAC Pitcher of the Week (2/19), (4/2)
- Fourth in the nation with 11 victories and fifth in the nation in starts
- Appeared in 15 games for the Yellow Jackets in the 2018 season, earning 14 starts
- Struck out 126, the top mark in the nation and a program record
- Posted a 11-3 record with a 2.60 ERA.
- Set a program record for both starts and wins
- Compiled a 2.60 ERA in 97.0 innings pitched
- Lead the team in strikeouts with 126
- Recorded 14 strikeouts in a 10-5 win over Washington & Lee (3/31)
- In 13 of 15 appearances, had six or more strikeouts per game
- In his three-year career, Selby is 17-3 for a winning percentage of .850
- Hurled a complete game with 10 strikeouts in a 2-1 win vs. No. 6 LeGrange in the NCAA Regional (5/17)
As a Sophomore – 2017:
- Appeared in 5 games with 4 starts
- 3-1 record with 3.05 ERA
- 21 strikeouts in 20.2 innings
- 3 hitless innings with 3 strikeouts in winning first start vs. RPI
- Fanned 6 in 5 innings in win at St. Mary’s (Md.)
- Won at Guilford with 5 hits and 1 earned run in 5 innings with 5 strikeouts
As a Freshman – 2016:
- Earned 10 starts on the mound for the Yellow Jackets
- Pitched a total of 53.1 innings tallying 45 strikeouts.
- Retired Rowan’s first 10 batters
- Selected ODAC Pitcher of the Week (2/28)
- Pitched a complete game and recorded 8 strikeouts against Shenandoah (4/30).
- Finished the season with a 4-1 record.
Personal: Earned three varsity letters in baseball at Western Branch High School, where he helped lead the Bruins to a 6A State Championship in 2014, a year that also included a 6A South Regional championship, a Conference 2 tournament title, and a Conference 2 regular season title…in 2015, Selby helped the Bruins to another Conference 2 regular season championship and a second straight 6A South Regional Championship…As a senior pitcher, Selby was named the Conference Co-Player of the Year, First Team All-Region, Second Team All-State, All-Tidewater Pitcher, and First Team All-Conference…Was also honored as a Second Team All-Conference outfielder.
Sleby was a DECA and FBLA member, and he intends to pursue a pre-medical degree…His uncle, Chuck Nightingale, played football at Notre Dame.